Critique of the Realist Approach from a Historical, Conceptual, and Disciplinary Perspective
Main Article Content
Abstract
The realist approach in International Relations is often declared to be the discipline itself. From its origins, through various circumstances and theoretical debates, to the first quarter of the 21st century, its place and prestige, although questioned, remain in the practice of international politics and within the disciplinary epistemic community. However, from a historical perspective of the discipline's evolution, one that reviews and questions its foundations, this position can be challenged. Therefore, the objective of this article is to propose a critique using the methodology of conceptual history, reflectivist metatheory, and empirical analysis. The result is that realism in the discipline has been politically motivated and oriented, which calls into question its supposed scientific objectivity, in addition to presenting persistent inconsistencies in its ontological and epistemological foundations. This hinders the understanding of the problem of international change in other contexts, and is insufficient for analyzing, for example, current borders. It is concluded that while realism can contribute normative terms and reflections, it is only one limited approach within a broader and richer array of theories, which is why academics are invited to explore the multiple theoretical possibilities based on a historical, situated, and conceptual understanding of the discipline.
Downloads
Article Details
Section

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Authors who publish in this journal accept the following conditions:
1. The authors keep the copyright and assign to the journal Comentario Internacional the right of the first publication, with the work registered with the attribution license of Creative Commons, which allows third parties to use what is published whenever they mention the authorship of the work and the first publication in this journal.
2. Authors can make other independent and additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the article published in this journal (eg, include it in an institutional repository or publish it in a book) provided they clearly indicate that the work was published for the first time in Comentario Internacional.
How to Cite
References
Artehistoria. 2024. “El naturalismo alemán: otra forma de realismo”. Artehistoria. 1 de abril. https://www.artehistoria.com/contextos/el-naturalismo-aleman-otra-forma-de-realismo
Ashley, Richard. 1984. “The Poverty of Neorealism”. En International Organization 38 (2): 225-261.
Barzun, Jacques. 2002. Del amanecer a la decadencia. Quinientos años de vida cultural en Occidente. Madrid: Taurus.
Benedetti, Alejandro. 2023. Palabras clave para el estudio de fronteras. Teseopress. https://www.teseopress.com/palabrasclavefronteras/front-matter/presentacion/
Borda, Sandra. 2014. Relaciones Internacionales y fronteras. Bogotá: Departamento de Ciencia Política - Universidad de los Andes.
Cabrera, Ernesto. 2014. “La invención del realismo político. un ejercicio de historia conceptual”. Signos Filosóficos XVI, no. 32: 126-149. https://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=34335734005
Cox, Robert. 1994. “Fuerzas sociales, estados y órdenes mundiales: más allá de la teoría de las relaciones internacionales”. En Vásquez, John (Comp.). Relaciones Internacionales: el pensamiento de los clásicos. México: Limusa.
Deleuze, Gilles y Félix Guattari. 1997. ¿Qué es la filosofía? Barcelona: Anagrama.
Etimologías. 2024. “Etimología de realismo”. Etimologías. 21 de marzo. https://etimologias.dechile.net/?realismo
García, Manuel. s.f. Lecciones preliminares de filosofía. Bogotá: ediciones nacionales.
García Pinzón, Viviana. 2011. “Cooperación y seguridad en la guerra contra las drogas: el Plan Colombia y la Iniciativa Mérida”. Tesis de Maestría, Universidad de Chile. https://bibliotecadigital.uchile.cl/permalink/56UDC_INST/25canv/alma991000601079703936
Hoffmann, Stanley. 1979. Teorías contemporáneas sobre las Relaciones Internacionales. Madrid: Editorial Tecnos.
James E. Dougherty y Robert L., Pfaltzgraff. 1993. Teorías en punga en las Relaciones Internacionales. Buenos Aires: Grupo Editor Latinoamericano.
Keohane, Robert. 1986. Neorealism and Its Critics. New York: Columbia University Press.
Koselleck, Reinhart. 2009. “Un texto fundacional de Reinhart Koselleck. Introducción al Diccionario histórico de conceptos político-sociales básicos en lengua alemana”. Traducido por Luis Fernández. Revista Anthopos. Huellas del conocimiento 223: 100. https://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/articulo?codigo=2987444
———. 2012. Historia de conceptos. Estudios sobre semántica y pragmática del lenguaje político y social. Madrid: Trotta.
———. 2016. historia/Historia. Madrid: Mínima Trotta.
Lapid, Yosef. 1989. “The third debate: on the prospects of international theory in a post-positivist era”. En International Studies Quarterly 33, No. 3: 235-254.
Larousse. 2024. “Realisme”. Encyclopédie. 1 de abril. https://www.larousse.fr/encyclopedie/litterature/r%C3%A9alisme/176382
Madrigal Garzón, Alexander Emilio. 2017. “Contribución a la construcción de una teoría reflectivista del cambio internacional: un análisis teórico y crítico para una síntesis reflexiva”. Tesis de Maestría, Universidad Andina Simón Bolívar, Sede Ecuador. https://repositorio.uasb.edu.ec/handle/10644/5966
Mesa, Roberto. 1977. Teoría y práctica de Relaciones Internacionales. Madrid: Taurus.
Mingst, Karen. 2004. Essentials of International Relations. New York-London: W.W. Norton & Company.
Morgenthau, Hans. 1986. Política entre naciones. La lucha por el poder y la paz. Buenos Aires: Grupo Editor Latinoamericano.
———. Politics among nations. The struggle for power and peace. 1948. New York: Knopf.
Nevil, Johnson. 1991. Los límites de la ciencia política. Madrid: Editorial Tecnos.
Online Etimology Diccionary. 2024. “Realism”. Etymonline. 15 de marzo. https://www.etymonline.com/search?q=realismo&lc=es
Pereira. 2008. Diccionario de Relaciones Internacionales y Política Exterior. Barcelona: Ariel.
Pons, Anaclet. 2024. “Alemania, EE.UU. y la tradición realista atlántica (1880-1980)”. Clionauta: Blog de Historia. 22 de abril. https://doi.org/10.58079/mz13
Rochau, Ludwig von. 1853. Grundsätze der Realpolitik, angewendet auf die staatlichen Zustände Deutschlands. Stuttgart: K. Göpel. https://www.digitale-sammlungen.de/en/view/bsb10561071?page=,1
Schmidt, Brian. 1998. The political discourse of anarchy a disciplinary history of international relations. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Sodupe, Kepa. 2003. La teoría de las relaciones internacionales a comienzos del siglo XXI. Araba Kalea, Universidad del País Vasco.
Specter, Matthew. 2022. The Atlantic Realists. Empire and International Political Thought between Germany and the United States. California: Stanford University Press.
Vásquez, John (Comp.). 1994. Relaciones Internacionales: el pensamiento de los clásicos. México: Limusa.
———. 1996. “The post-positivist debate: reconstructing scientific enquiry and international relations theory after enlightenment’s fall”. En Booth, Ken and Smith, Steve (Eds.). International relations theory today. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Waltz, Kenneth. 1979. Theory of Internacional Polítics. Massachusetts: Addison-Wesley Publishing Company
Wendt, Alexander. 2003. Social Theory of International Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
